Mixtape vs Album: Does it Matter?

In a world of digital music consumption and mass piracy, the role and function of mixtape vs album are blurring.

The question is which is more valuable for aspiring rappers and producers? Here we lay out the positives of negatives of both to let you make up your own mind.


Mixtapes have always been an underground thing. A way of trying things out and building yourself as an artist to get the attention of a label and the support to get an album released.

However, there’s always the risk that giving away your music for free might devalue it. Eric Bernsen points out that “the mixtape evolved [and] went from being an exclusive item, which proved your connections to the streets, to a musical format, which helped launch the careers of rap’s biggest stars“. 

The great thing about mixtapes is that the artist is in complete control of releasing it so they can decide the length, content, etc. which allows them to break a lot more rules and be as experimental as they like.

When it comes to the mixtape vs album debate, a lot of artists bring this factor to the table: do you want to have complete artistic freedom? Or something more ready for the commercial stage?


Albums are seen as an artist’s polished, professional release, showcasing the best music they can make. Some artists see it as the best way to showcase your craft. Others see it as an outdated model designed only to move units and generate singles, but it is a business at the end of the day, so what’s wrong with that?

Of course, there’s no reason why you can’t use both to build your career. Eric Bernsen says that while artists may have less creative control on albums that are being funded by major labels, they’re still able to ‘feed the streets’ with mixtapes and provide the more ‘raw’ material which garnered their success in the first place.

We’d love to hear your thoughts. Are mixtapes a format truly adapted to the modern music industry? Or are albums the only true way for an artist to show off their craft? Let us know what you think in the comments below, and whether you’d be picking a mixtape vs album?

Ready to hire? Our marketplace of over 410,000 freelancers has the skills and expertise needed to skyrocket your business to the next level. From marketers to designers, copywriters to SEO experts – browse the talented bunch here!

Joe Scarffe

Joe is the CMO at Twine.

When he’s not moaning about the state of the music industry or public transport in Manchester, he works with the Twine community and handles social media, the blog and partnerships with companies and institutions.